Dialysis Safety Series Clinical Safety Resources
Dialysis is not safe. Accidents will happen unexpectedly.
The nurse is the last line of defense. These pages are your preparation.
Vigilance — Critical Thinking — Rapid Action
Case Study: Empty Acid Concentrate – Dialysis Safety
Back to Safety Series Home
Critical Incident Case Study

Empty Acid Concentrate

When Water-Only Dialysis Triggers Hemolysis, Hyperkalemia, and Dialyzer Rupture
Incident Type: Concentrate Error Dialysis Unit — Multiple Machines 1 Patient Severely Affected Severity: Life-Threatening
Empty Acid Water-Only Dialysis Osmotic Pressure Variation RBC Rupture (Hemolysis) Massive K⁺ Release Severe Hyperkalemia Dialyzer Rupture Blood Loss + Anemia + Infection
One empty acid canSeven catastrophic failuresOne patient fighting for their life

The Machine May Not Alarm — But the Patient Will

No acid = no electrolytes = water-only dialysis.
When water enters the dialyzer, it causes osmotic lysis of red blood cells. The potassium released from ruptured RBCs can cause fatal hyperkalemia in minutes. The machine may not alarm because conductivity may still read normal if the machine has a bypass mechanism that allows water to flow when acid is empty.

Event Timeline What Happened — Step by Step

T+0
⚠️ Empty Acid Concentrate
The acid concentrate can on the dialysis machine was empty. The machine did not alarm or stop — it continued to run.
T+2
💧 Water-Only Dialysis Begins
Without acid concentrate, the machine mixed pure water with bicarbonate only. No sodium, no potassium, no calcium — just water and buffer. The patient's blood is now being dialyzed against water.
T+5
🧪 Osmotic Pressure Variation
Dialysate is now hypotonic compared to blood. Water moves into red blood cells. Red blood cells swell and burst.
T+10
🩸 RBC Rupture — Massive Hemolysis
Red blood cells rupture en masse. The dialysate turns pink/red — a visible sign of hemolysis. Hemoglobin is released into the blood and dialysate.
T+12
⚡ Massive Potassium Release
Each ruptured RBC releases its intracellular potassium. Massive K⁺ is dumped into the bloodstream. Blood potassium rises from normal (4.0 mmol/L) to dangerous levels (>7.0 mmol/L).
T+15
🫀 Severe Hyperkalemia — Cardiac Risk
Patient develops severe hyperkalemia. ECG shows peaked T-waves, widened QRS. Risk of cardiac arrest is imminent. Patient must be dialyzed urgently again to remove the excess potassium.
T+20
💥 Dialyzer Rupture
The dialyzer membrane ruptures. Massive blood loss occurs — blood pours into the drain. The machine may alarm for a blood leak, but significant blood has already been lost.
T+30
🩺 Consequences: Anemia + Infection
Patient survives but now faces:
  • Severe anemia — from massive RBC destruction and blood loss
  • Infection risk — from blood exposure and compromised immune response
  • Need for blood transfusion — and extended hospital stay

Physiology of Hemolysis Why Water-Only Dialysis Destroys RBCs

Hypotonic Dialysate

Normal dialysate is isotonic (similar osmotic pressure to blood). Water-only dialysate is hypotonic (lower osmotic pressure). Water moves into RBCs to equalize pressure.

RBC Swelling & Rupture

RBCs swell like balloons until they burst. Each RBC releases:
~ 120 mmol/L K⁺ + hemoglobin + other intracellular contents

Potassium Cascade

Massive K⁺ release from ruptured RBCs → hyperkalemia. Normal K⁺: 3.5–5.0 mmol/L  |  Dangerous: > 6.5 mmol/L

Urgent Re-Dialysis

Patient must be dialyzed again urgently — but now with correct dialysate. The second dialysis removes the excess potassium and restores electrolyte balance.

The Machine May Not Alarm — But the Patient Will

Some dialysis machines have a bypass mechanism that allows water to flow to the dialyzer even when acid concentrate is empty. The machine may not alarm because:

  • Conductivity may still read "normal" if the machine has a conductivity sensor that measures total ionic strength — but water has no ions to measure
  • Some machines have separate sensors for acid and bicarbonate — if only one fails, the machine may not alarm
  • The patient's symptoms (cramps, nausea, hypotension) are the real alarm

Never assume the machine will protect the patient. — Always verify concentrate levels and check for signs of hemolysis.

Clinical Lessons What We Learned

Lesson 1
⚠️ Never Assume the Machine Will Alarm

Some machines do not alarm when acid is empty. Conductivity sensors may not detect the absence of acid if the machine has a bypass mechanism.

Lesson 2
🩸 Visible Hemolysis = Emergency

Pink/red dialysate is a CRITICAL SIGN of hemolysis. Stop dialysis immediately. Do not return blood to the patient.

Lesson 3
⚡ Hyperkalemia Can Kill in Minutes

Ruptured RBCs release massive amounts of potassium. ECG monitoring is essential — look for peaked T-waves and widened QRS.

Lesson 4
🔄 Urgent Re-Dialysis is Required

After an acute hemolytic event, the patient must be dialyzed urgently with correct dialysate to remove the excess potassium and clear free hemoglobin.

Lesson 5
💥 Dialyzer Rupture = Massive Blood Loss

Hemolysis can damage the dialyzer membrane, leading to rupture. Blood loss can be massive — requiring transfusion and intensive care.

Lesson 6
🦠 Anemia + Infection = Prolonged Recovery

The patient now faces severe anemia from RBC destruction and blood loss, plus increased infection risk from immune compromise and blood exposure.

🛡️ Prevention
✅ The Only Solution: Systematic Prevention

Prevention is the only cure. Every dialysis machine must have:

  • Acid concentrate level monitoring — visual and electronic
  • Conductivity alarms that trigger immediate shutdown if values fall outside normal range
  • Two-person verification of concentrate connections before each treatment
  • Staff training on recognizing signs of hemolysis and acting immediately

Conclusion

This event demonstrates that machines are not fail-safe. A simple empty acid can — a small oversight — can trigger a cascade of catastrophic events:

The machine may not alarm. The patient will. Trust your eyes, not the screen.

Prevention is the only cure. Every shift, every patient — verify the concentrate.

✍️ Author: Ahmed Mohmad Rashyd Musleh Registered Staff Nurse